top of page

Is Social Media Really Free? EU Case C-643/25 and Cyprus Businesses

11 hours ago
3 min read

Legal Review | EU Consumer Law, Data Protection & Digital Business | 21 November 2026


The 30-second answer


On 19 November 2026, Advocate General Laila Medina delivered her Opinion in Case C-643/25, Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband v Meta Platforms Ireland. She proposed that supplying personal data and consenting to its commercial use can amount to consideration for access to a digital service. On that interpretation, a platform cannot necessarily promote itself as ‘free’ if the user is required to give that consideration. This is an Advocate General’s Opinion, not a judgment of the Court of Justice.


What happened in the Meta case?


The dispute originated from Facebook’s February 2015 registration statement in Germany that Facebook ‘is and remains free’. A German consumer association challenged the statement because users supplied data and agreed to commercial use of that data in return for accessing the social network. The German Federal Court of Justice referred the legal issue to the Court of Justice of the European Union.

The interpretation concerns point 20 of Annex I to Directive 2005/29/EC, the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, which addresses marketing products as ‘free’, ‘gratis’ or ‘without charge’ where the consumer has to pay more than specified unavoidable costs.


What did the Advocate General propose?


The Opinion treats an economically valuable exchange as potentially relevant even when no money changes hands. Personal data used for advertising and other commercial purposes may have value to the operator. The proposal distinguishes this from personal-data processing exclusively necessary for providing the service or complying with legal obligations.

The Court has not yet given its judgment. The Opinion is influential legal reasoning but is not binding. It would be incorrect to describe this as a final CJEU ruling or as a general prohibition on no-fee digital services.


Why this matters to Cyprus businesses


Businesses operating websites, apps, subscriptions, online communities and consumer-facing platforms in Cyprus should review the accuracy of their marketing claims. A promise of ‘free’ access should be checked against what the consumer must supply, agree to, or permit in exchange. Whether a particular practice is lawful depends on the actual business model, the consumer-facing wording, the data flows and the applicable law.

The Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) regulate different issues. Transparent advertising does not by itself establish a lawful basis for personal-data processing; GDPR compliance does not automatically determine whether a consumer-law claim is misleading.


A practical five-point legal checklist


  • Review ‘free’, ‘no cost’ and ‘complimentary’ statements on advertisements, sign-up pages, landing pages and onboarding screens.

  • Map the personal data required to register and distinguish operationally necessary processing from commercial uses such as behavioural advertising.

  • Assess the actual legal basis and consent flows for each processing purpose under applicable data-protection rules.

  • Check consistency between the advertising headline, privacy notice, cookie choices, platform terms and customer agreements.

  • Record the decisions, update client-facing documents where needed and set a review point for the eventual Court judgment.


Frequently asked questions


Has the Court already ruled that social media is not free?

No. As at 21 November 2026, this is the Advocate General’s Opinion in Case C-643/25, delivered on 19 November 2026, and not the Court’s final judgment.


Does using customer data always mean that a service has a price?

No automatic conclusion follows. The Opinion focuses on data provided and consented to for commercial exploitation, and expressly recognises an important distinction for processing exclusively necessary to provide the service or comply with legal obligations.


Do Cyprus businesses need to change their website terms immediately?

Not every business needs the same change. It is sensible to audit the actual marketing message, contractual exchange and data-processing purposes before deciding whether any amendment is required.


Legal review of digital platforms and commercial terms in Cyprus


Cyprus Law Chambers advises on commercial and technology agreements, platform terms, contractual allocation of responsibilities and connected legal issues. A focused review can examine what the business promises, what users provide in return, which documents describe the arrangement, and whether separate data-protection or specialist technical advice is required.



An introductory call is subject to availability, conflict checks and acceptance of instructions. Please send only a brief, non-confidential outline initially.


Official sources


General legal information only. The Advocate General’s Opinion is not a judgment. This article does not constitute advice on any specific platform, consumer claim or processing activity. Cyprus Law Chambers™ — Law Chambers Nicos Papacleovoulou LLC.

bottom of page